Britain's finance chief Confronts A Most Significant Problem: The EU Exit Conundrum
Rachel Reeves has tackled the imminent spending review like a unwilling swimmer creeping into icy water, striving to mitigate the discomfort through step-by-step immersion.
First Moves and Revenue Commitments
She commenced addressing the issue of insufficient revenue towards the conclusion of the summer months. At first, she declined to uphold former statements that increases in taxation in the prior year's financial statement would be the final ones.
Subsequently, in early November, she took a bolder step into the freezing waters. Her address vowed to "do what is necessary" to support government services and keep borrowing costs down.
Election Commitment and Government Backtrack
Within 10 days, the exchequer had pulled back the implication. The manifesto commitment remained intact after all. Like every cold-water bather knows, this cancelled immersion and trembling pullback is the most painful of all methods. Nothing extends the pain like hesitation.
It is challenging to be resolute when selecting between degrees of internally generated damage.
Optimism as Approach
Hope has not been a successful tactic for this government. Central of the prime minister's election bid was the vain hope of in some way satisfying the public's call for better government services without undoing significant amounts of Conservative tax cuts.
Communication Deficiency
Not once has both the prime minister or Reeves adequately expressed a sense of shared mission to explain all this pain. To some extent that is a problem of leadership presence. The prime minister and the chancellor are strikingly similar in their poor communication skills, stilted and reticent in a way that drives listeners away instead of drawing them closer.
Brexit Agreement and Financial Reality
Just as political pressure to support government services has compelled the finance ministry to acknowledge that taxes must go up, the commercial requirement of improving prosperity makes it ever harder to disregard the cost of detachment from the continental trading bloc.
European Partnership and Negotiations
Officials devoted a year splashing in the initial phase of realignment with the EU: proposals to remove import controls on farm products; a student movement initiative. Aspiration went a further on energy, military and protection collaboration, but no major deals has to date been signed.
Diplomatic Reality and International Standing
Lacking specific instruction and drive from the prime minister's office, discussions are stuck. Brussels authorities says single-market privileges are obtained with contributions to the continental treasury. Government representatives are aware that's the deal. That doesn't make them keen for a public row and Nigel Farage howling treason over the eventual amount ends up being paid.
Financial Impact and Government Wording
Financial circumstances has triggered some shift in Labour's language on the EU relationship. She has begun naming EU withdrawal alongside the health emergency as a cause of economic damage that the finance ministry is toiling to address. Cabinet members have followed suit, although they cautiously attribute the fault to "a bad Brexit deal" or "the manner of departure", never just "leaving".
Geopolitical Situation and Future Outlook
The issue of the UK's long-term partnership with the European Union can't be limited to technical adjustments and customs systems when the entire international system is in significant transformation. Considering everything that has happened since 2016, it feels legitimate still to be raising the core matter: were Britain's interests promoted by exiting the European Union?
Conclusion
These are sobering, challenging realities about the UK's situation in choppy world affairs. It is understandable that both leaders flinch from the challenge. It would take them outside their comfort zone, into currents that they will not oppose. So rather they continue nervously moving along the coastline, praying that perhaps shortly the circumstances will shift.